best 4 cup coffee maker reviews

The 7 Best 4 Cup Coffee Maker (Purchase Advice 2020)

November 30, 2019anbk09

Making your morning cup of joe is a great experience for every working adult, however, when your coffee maker stops working on you, then you might be in for some rough mornings. If this is the boat you’re in, then you are in the market for a new coffee pot. Well, with so many options on the market, it can be tough to know which 4 cup coffee makers are worth the price.

So, we have narrowed down a list of some of the best options and have taken the time to give a comprehensive review of each product. This will allow you to pick from the best of the best and get yourself the choice that works for you. So, pick one of the options on this list and you will have the best 4-cup coffee maker around.

Quick Comparison: Top 7 Best 4 Cup Coffee Makers on the Market

1. Mr. Coffee Simple Brew 4 Cup Coffee Maker

This Mr. Coffee model has a power light so that you can clearly see when the coffee pot is on and brewing and a water level indicator that shows you how much water you are pouring into the compartment.

This coffee maker also comes with an auto-pause function that allows you to remove the carafe and pour yourself a cup before the brewing cycle is done. The glass carafe has measurement markings on the front so that you can see how much coffee was actually made and so that you can pour an exact amount.

The removable filter basket allows for easy clean-up and the pot comes with a stain-resistant warming plate that keeps the carafe heated and the coffee warm for serving after the brewing cycle is finished.


  • Has power light indicator
  • Comes with water light indicator
  • Has auto-pause function
  • Measurement markings on carafe for accurate pouring
  • Removeable filter basket
  • Warming plate


  • The brewing cycle can be pretty loud when turned on
  • The cycle takes a while to brew a full pot
  • Compact, but not the longest- lasting product

2. Krups KM202850 Simply Brew Compact Filter Drip 5-Cup Coffee Maker

This KRUPS 5-cup coffee maker is a compact option that will hold a bit more than some of the other machines. With a 5-cup capacity, this machine holds more liquid and allows you to make the amount that you need each morning.

The carafe is made with a no-drip spout so that there won’t be a mess when you pour and the machine allows you to take out the carafe and pour a cup of coffee while the pot is still brewing. This feature pauses the brew cycle until you replace the carafe so that you can get out of the house in the morning when you are in a rush.

This model’s stainless-steel finish gives the machine a sleek look and keeps smudges from staying on the coffee maker. This product purchase includes a coffee spoon so that you can scoop out the amount needed each morning.


  • Compact with 5-cup capacity
  • Has a no-drip spout
  • Pause and Pour feature
  • Stainless-steel finish
  • Includes a coffee spoon with purchase


  • Difficult to pout water into compartment with lid in the way
  • Doesn’t come with an automatic shut-off system
  • Doesn’t heat coffee to a hot temperature

3. Zojirushi EC DAC50 Zutto 5-Cup Drip Coffee Maker

This Zojirushi 5-cup coffee maker has a unique design that offers you a tapered carafe and a simple, sleek style that is compact enough to keep in a small vacation or beach house. This drip coffee maker has the drip cone inside of the decanter, allowing it to be more compact.

This machine comes with a replaceable water filter that makes maintenance simple and easy, and a measuring spoon is included with a purchase so that you can scoop out the coffee correctly. This product also comes with a keep-warm function that will sustain a medium heat to keep your brewed coffee warm for a longer time.

There is a user manual that comes with this option and this item includes a 1-year limited warranty that will cover defects and manufacturer’s malfunctions.


  • 5-cup capacity
  • Compact size for small spaces
  • Drip cone located inside the decanter
  • Comes with replaceable water filter
  • Includes a measuring spoon
  • Has keep-warm function
  • Comes with 1-year warranty


  • Charcoal filter doesn’t last very long, needs replacing often
  • Produces a lot of steam, can't be placed under a cabinet
  • The coffee doesn’t come out at a hot temperature

4. Elite Cuisine EHC-2022 Maxi Matic 4 Cup

This Elite Cuisine 4 cup coffee maker is a compact option that will give you piping hot coffee every morning. The 4-cup capacity allows you to make enough for multiple people, or not, but doesn’t take up too much counter space.

The coffee carafe is dishwasher safe and makes for easy cleaning, and the swing-out filter compartment comes with a reusable and washable built-in filter.


The power indicator light tells you when the machine is on so that you can see it working and a water level indicator shows you how much liquid you have poured in so that you make the right amount of coffee.

This product comes with a unique feature that allows you to take out the carafe and pour yourself a cup while the machine is still brewing so that you can get your coffee while others is still being made. This works great when you are in a rush in the morning and need to grab your cup and go.


  • 4 cup capacity
  • Carafe is dishwasher safe
  • Swing-out filter compartment
  • Reusable, built-in filter
  • Comes with power and water level indicators
  • Pause and Serve function for pouring while brewing


  • Brewing cycle takes a while
  • The glass carafe is not very durable
  • Must let the glass cool before washing

5. Cuisinart DCC-450BK 4-Cup Coffee Maker 

This Cuisinart 4-cup coffee maker comes with a stainless steel carafe that has a dripless spout and knuckle guard. This machine has a 30-minute shut-off switch so that it will keep the coffee warm, but shut off after a while so that it won't be left on throughout the day.

This machine comes with a Brew-Pause feature that allows you to pause the brewing process and remove the carafe to pour yourself a cup. This model also comes with a power light indicator and is BPA-free so that you know there are no unwanted chemicals used in the making of this coffee pot.

This Cuisinart machine offers you the choice of a black or red coffee pot so that you can get the color that matches the style and design of your kitchen.


  • 4-cup capacity
  • Stainless-steel carafe
  • Comes with dripless spout and knuckle guard
  • Comes with 30-minute shut-off
  • Brew-Pause feature
  • BPA-free


  • The lid must be closed completely or the coffee will not drain, and will spill over
  • Heating pad paint is known to peel easily
  • The coffee doesn’t stay hot very long in the carafe

6. Bonavita BV1500TS 5-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker

This Bonavita 5-cup coffee maker is a one-touch machine that allows you to start the brew operation with one button, and it comes with an automatic shut-off. The 1100-watt heater helps keeps the temperature at the optimal brewing heat so that you get hot coffee every time.

The optional pre-infusion mode works to saturate the ground coffee to allow for degassing before the brewing cycle. This machine also comes with a specially-designed showerhead that is ideal for extraction and works great for small batch sizes.

This carafe is made from double-layers of stainless steel and has a thermal carafe style that helps retain heat to keep the coffee warm. This machine works fairly quickly with all 5 cups being made in about 6 minutes.


  • 5-cup capacity
  • One-touch technology with automatic shut-off
  • 1100-watt heater
  • Pre-infusion mode for degassing before brewing
  • Specially-designed showerhead
  • Double stainless-steel carafe
  • Brewing cycle last about 6 minutes


  • Doesn’t use US standards cup sizes (uses European 4.25-ounce standard)
  • Spout design leaves a bit of coffee in the carafe every time
  • Must put the lid on the carafe to pour the coffee

7. BLACK+DECKER DCM600B 5-Cup Coffee Maker

This Black and Decker model makes up to 5 cups of coffee in the 25-ounce carafe and comes with measurement markings to ensure the proper liquid amount. The carafe comes with an easy-grip handle so that your hand will feel more comfortable while pouring.

This model comes with a removable filter basket that is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning and is compatible with basket-style paper filters. The carafe plate is non-stick and warms the coffee for up to an hour after the brewing cycle is done so that the liquid stays at a higher temperature.

The machine has a water level indicator that allows you to clearly see how much liquid is being poured into the compartment so that you can have the right amount for how many cups you need. This coffee pot also comes with a power light that allows you to know that the pot is on and brewing.


  • 5-cup capacity
  • 25-ounce carafe with measure markings
  • Easy-grip handle
  • Comes with removeable filter basket
  • Carafe plate is non-stick and has keep-warm function
  • Water level indicator for accurate measurements
  • Power light indicator


  • Comes with warranty that doesn’t cover shipping costs for replacement
  • Brews a weaker flavor than other options
  • Will stop brewing if the carafe is removed

Things You Need To Consider Before Buying 4 Cup Coffee Maker

When purchasing a coffee maker, there are several things that you want to think about to ensure that you get a quality product. Here are the things that you should consider before settling on one product.


Knowing that you want a durable coffee pot that will last will help you focus on the quality of the materials and allow you to get an option that is made to last a long time for years of use.


Whether you need a large pot for a house full of people, or you need a single cup machine for yourself, you want to get the right fit for you. So, make sure that you think about the size you need and have space for.


If you are looking for a budget-friendly option, then searching for a model with the newest technologies will not allow you to stay within that budget. So, look for something that will work better for the price that you can afford so that you can get a good product with all the basic necessities.

Easy to Clean

If you know that your busy schedule will likely not allow you to get a complicated product that is difficult to clean, then getting a machine washable model will better fit your lifestyle.

Common Problems Associated with Using 4 Cup Coffee Maker

The Coffee Maker Isn’t Working

This problem can be seen by many different coffee pot brands and models for a number of different reasons. One of the most common, and the simplest to fix – besides forgetting to plug it in – is that the water reservoir was not filled. This is a common issue when multiple people use the machine and someone turns it on when there is no water.

Most models will sense that there is no water and shut off, or stay on without starting the brewing process. So, double-check that the water is sufficient before turning it on.

Another issue, which could be a much bigger problem, is an electrical wiring connection malfunction. The electrical components are not eternal, and there could be manufacturing defects or other wiring issues that could cause the electric parts to stop working. If this happens, then you will likely have to send it off for repairs or replacement.

Steam Pressure Drop

The steam pressure will not remain exactly the same at all times, and it can change a bit depending on whether the machine was recently opened or not. The initial drop in pressure is nothing to worry about, though.

When the machine initially warms up and begins the brewing process, the machine is cold and must heat up. The machine starts and stops heating based on internal pressure measurement, both air and steam pressurize inside and create a false steam pressure that makes it higher than average with a huge drop.

Once the machine is opened you will usually see a 0.1 - 0.3 pressure drop at the steam gauge because a rush of pressurized air is escaping. At that point, the coffee pot has to reheat and create only steam pressure and not steam and air pressure.

Coffee Doesn’t Drip, or Drips Very Slowly

In many drip coffee makers, after some time, you may find that the coffee pot doesn't drip or drips very slowly. This can be frustrating and annoying when you expected it to work properly, but this doesn’t mean that the whole machine is ruined.

Often times, drip coffee makers can get clogged, which stops the flow of coffee from dripping into the carafe. So, unclogging the lines may do the trick. To do this, all you do is fill the water compartment with hot water. It will heat the water itself, but having the water hot already will help moves around any grounds that are clogging the drip even better.

Then, you will want to pour the remaining part of the container with white vinegar. Together, the hot water and vinegar work to loosen any hardened clogs and pieces of build-up while getting rid of the odor and disinfecting the machine as well. You can continue this process multiple times if you only see a small improvement until the drip is as it should be.

Insufficient Coffee Temperature

If you are having an issue with getting your coffee to reach the correct temperature, then there may be a problem with the heating element. Because this depends largely on the type of unit you have, this can vary widely, but the heating element typically will cause the water to boil and enter into the coffee maker so that if it doesn’t heat, then the coffee maker will not work.

If this happens, then replacing the heating elements will be the only solution. However, if your coffee maker is working, but it doesn’t offer the heating temperatures that you want, then you can do a few things to help aid the process.

First, you can heat the water before pouring it into the compartment. This will help keep the water at a higher temperature and make your coffee come out hotter. You can also pre-heat the carafe, which can actually add another 10-15 degrees to your coffee.

Pump Makes Noise

When getting a cheaper coffee maker, certain things are focused on to ensure that the product is basic but still gets the job done. This means that some manufacturers will not spend the money on a silent or low-noise pump for their machines. When buying an inexpensive option, a louder pump will likely be an issue.

However, if your machine has never made that sound before, then that could be a sign of a problem. The first thing you should check is if the machine is clogged. This could result in a noise that sounds like the pump but is the sound of water trying to get through the blockage. Another reason could be that there are loose parts in the machine. In this case, you would be able to shake the machine to see if it continues.

If it is due to loosened parts, then you will have to take apart the machine and see what is going on inside. Once the parts are put together properly, then the noise level will go back to the normal volume.

Leaking Water

If you have been having a problem with water leaking out from your coffee maker, then there is likely a problem with the pump valve. If this valve is broken or has a clog, then the water will not be able to be pushed up and into the tube to go to the carafe. The water needs to go somewhere, so when the machine is turned on, the water will spill out onto the countertop.

To fix this issue, you first want to see if there is a clog. If there is, then you will not need to replace the valve and instead just unclog it. However, if the valve is broken, then you will need to replace it with a new one before using the coffee maker again.

Coffee Drips Too Fast

When you are making your coffee, there is a normal speed at which the coffee will drip. If it is too slow, it can be caused by a clog, but what if it drips too fast? This could cause the coffee to not be properly filtered and taste bitter. 

The trick here is to adjust the fineness of the grind. If the drip is too slow, then you will need to try a coarser grind. However, if the drip is going too fast, then you may need to try a finer grind to get the brew that you want.

After Turning on the Device for About 2 Minutes, All the Lights on the Keys Clicked and the Coffee Did Not Work

In this particular case, there could be any number of things that are causing your coffee maker to act this way. This could mean that the valve is broken, the pump is messed up, or that there is a major clog. So, when this happens, you want to turn off the machine and check all of the parts. If there is an issue identified, fix it and turn the machine back on. If it works properly, then that was the issue.

However, if you don’t see anything wrong, then you will want to shut off the machine for at least an hour. When you turn it back on, if it still does the same thing, then you may need to call customer service.

Coffee Has a Plastic Smell After Brewing

If you get a new coffee maker, the smell of the plastic could make quite an odor. To get rid of this new coffee maker smell, you will want to mix a solution of white vinegar and hot water into the machine and run it through a brew cycle. Then rinse it with soap and water, and the smell will be gone.

How to Prepare Delicious Coffee

Making your morning cup of coffee may not much effort with a coffee maker, but there are a few things that you can do to make it taste better. First, you want to get a good brand of coffee. This will help you get the most out of your machine. Getting freshly roasted beans will give you more flavor, so pay attention to date to get the most recent.

You can also choose to buy whole beans and grind them yourself. This is more time-consuming in the morning, but for weekend mornings, it can give you a great cup of coffee. However, an easier way to get a better taste is to get the ratio right. The average ratio is 16:1, so measuring out the amounts to get the perfect ratio will make a big difference.


Several coffee makers will give you a decent cup of coffee, but getting the right product for you depends on a lot of factors. So, make sure that whichever product you choose to purchase will be the right fit for your needs, and you have the best 4-cup coffee maker for you.

Previous Post Next Post